Eureka Eatery

Reviews

• Kev D.

  star star star star star 7 June 2026

  I've always been skeptical of establishments located inside gas stations that serve food. I've actually never eaten food that was prepared inside of a gas station. I have never dined in, but they do offer limited seating in the area of the gas station where they are located and could probably seat 12 comfortably.
  
  In regard to the food, I ordered the original gyro and truffle fries. The original gyro does come with lettuce, which I'm not a huge fan of. I'm more traditional and only like tomato and onion on my gyro, but that's not a deal breaker as I can just request no lettuce. The gyro itself is huge, and is priced fairly in my opinion. The house made Tzatziki is 10/10 and does come on the sandwich. I have also tried the Ultimate Shawarma and it is REALLY great as we. I was pleasantly surprised at the quality and quantity of food being served at this gas station. My only complaint is that I do not live closer. Will definitely be back. Keep up the good work Eureka Gyro!

• Nancy B.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 2 June 2026

  Totally did not live up to all the rave reviews. So I don't mind that it's in a gas station, but nobody said that it does not have seating. Ok, there are 2 tables, if you want to sit on stools. Hard ones. Then you will have to put up with people constantly walking past you or standing waiting for their food. It's fine for carry out and I wish someone had said as much.
  
  As for the food, it was pretty good but no awards here. Loved the waffle fries and the schwarma was fine. We found the menu difficult to make out. It certainly was not a typical menu, but then, it's more of a take-out place so I suppose they are limited because of that.
  
  If we lived here we would probably try it again, knowing what to expect but since we are from out of town that won't happen. By the way, it appears to be mostly a liquor store inside.

• Andrea C.

  star star star star star 29 May 2026

  Yes!  Yes!  YES!!
  
  this place has been popping up on my Instagram feed for some time.  It's in a gas station and I just never went cuz, well, it's in a gas station.  Like online dating, I have learned to not judge by appearances!
  
  I love chicken shawarma and ordered one along with waffle fries and a side of garlic sauce.  That was the best darn shawarma I have ever had!  It was grilled to perfection.  
  
  Naturally I had to go back a few days later for a repeat meal.  This time I added on some baklava. They sell walnut and pistachio baklava - personally, I preferred the walnut but I would not be disappointed if they only had pistachio.  I will be back...possibly even this evening!

• Jason L.

  star star star star_border star_border 24 May 2026

  We went for the highly rated Nashville Hot chicken sandwiches and based on many reviews we were very exited. We knew the restaurant was inside of a gas station but so our expectations on the dining experience wasn't very high, even still we were disappointed. There were only two community style tables and both of them were very dirty and sticky. The sandwiches were high quality but their spice scale leans very HOT, think Thai food, but hotter. I can handle quite a bit of spice but my sandwich was nearly inedible and it was rated "hot" just above the middle of the scale and still two away from the hottest.

• Catlyn G.

  star star star star star_border 22 May 2026

  I see this place advertised EVERYWHERE- Facebook, Instagram. I finally gave in and decided we to give them a try. I got their hummus and pita chips & some and truffle fries.. AMAZING! Definitely will be going back. Good food & good service!!